.

wpe8.jpg (12616 bytes)

logoemcw.gif (16843 bytes)

.

Reprinted from the EIC/EMCW report of the proceedings.

Abstract: The object of this paper is to aid in the selection of specifications for wire being used as transformer bobbin pins.

Key words: bobbin pin wire, bobbin pin, pin lead, terminal pin.

I. INTRODUCTION

In recent years, a growing demand using transformer bobbins with pins as leads, has combined with the growth of the worldwide industry. As such, many manufacturers are purchasing, producing, and supplying product to many and various end user, industry, and military specifications.

This paper will address various base metal and plating considerations for wire used as bobbin pin leads.

II. DISCUSSION

All wires produced today are produced to specifications. Wire is measured and compared to selected production specifications to see if it was produced correctly, so   it can perform properly in the application. Specifications must be selected properly    and be capable of determining if the wire is functionally appropriate in order for the applications to perform as required.

A. Base Metal Alloys

Most bobbin pin materials come from the list of alloys and specifications below:        

Alloy Name  

UNS No.

   
ETP Copper C11000
OF Copper       C10200
Beryllium Copper C17200
Gilding Alloy C21000
Phosphor Bronze 5% Sn C51000
80-20 Copper Nickel C71000
Copper Nickel Tin      C72500
Nickel Silver 18% Ni      C75200
52 Alloy Nickel-Iron    52 Alloy

These alloys have been selected for various reasons: chemistry, thermal conductivity, strength, formability, coefficient of expansion and availability. (See Table 1.) Alloys     are created typically for solid solution strength at solution phase optimums. Increased copper per centages provide increased conductivity; increased nickel provides     strength, lower expansion rates and elevated temperature service. 

B. Tempers

Although the tensile limits in these alloys reflect the Ultimate Tensile Strength capable of being achieved the extra hard and spring tempers are mostly used when producing straight pins. Otherwise, pins which have to be formed, or upset with retention features, or coined or swaged into tandem pin (end-to-end) configurations are specified from the much softer and more formable 1/2 Hard, 3/4 Hard or Hard tempers. (See Table 2.) Serious consideration should be given to the trade-off of formability and strength.

C. Cross-sections

Present designs are utilizing wire for pins with round, square and rectangular cross-sections. Mechanical property specifications for square wire are for the most   part, the same as that for round wire. Rectangular wire (or flat wire) will be considered mto have round/square mechanical properties when sizes have width-to-thickness   ratios is 3:1 or less. Wires which have ratios which are greater than 3:1 will use  industry specifications more typical for strip and/or stamped terminals.

Table 1.

Alloy Name UNS No. ASTM Spec Ultimate Tensile Strength ksi(MPs) Conductivity
% IACS
Coefficient
Thermal Expansion
per degree F to 300 F
ETP Copper C11000 B1,B2,B3 60 (413) 101 0.0000098
OF Copper C10200 B1,B2, B3 60 (413) 101 0.0000098
Beryllium Copper C17200 B 197 165 (1137) 22 0.0000099
Gilding Alloy C21000 B 134 72 (495) 56 0.0000100
70/30 Brass C28000 B 134 120 (830) 28 0.0000111
65/35 Brass C27000 B 134 120 (830) 27 0.0000113
Phosphor Bronze 5% C51000 B 159 130 (896) 20 0.0000099
80-20 CuproNickel C71000 B 208 85 (586) 6.5 0.0000091
Copper Nickel Tin C72500 B 122 115 (793) 11 0.0000092
Nickel Silver, 85% Ni C75200 B 208 111 (765) 8 0.0000090

Significant in the specifying of square and rectangular wire is that of the wires diagonal or corner radii. Specifying dimensions, along with total tolerance, (square, diagonal or corner radius) aids in refining control over pin size and its retention characteristics.    The formulae are below:

When  D = Diagonal
           S = Square Size
           R = Corner Radius

           D = 1.4142 S - .8284 radius
           R = 1.4142 S - D
                      and
           S =  D + .8284 R
                       1.4142

In the case of diagonals and corner radii, only one criteria should be specified, not   both. The more significant to pin retention is the diagonal. Also significant is alloy's coefficient of expansion. Nickel containing alloys are more stable during brief  excursions to elevated temperatures. Pin alloys should be selected on the basis          of the understanding pin and plastic expansion rates.

D. Electroplating and Coating

Gold, nickel, copper, tin and tin-lead electroplated finishes are the most common pin wire finishes. Electroplating allows the greatest control over thickness and uniformity. Hot dipped coatings of tin and tin-lead are more difficult to control in this respect.     Most hot dipped square and round pin wires have nominal coats of 25 micron, which although bright and attractive, is insufficient in thickness to maintain any required long term solderability shelf-life. Some round lead wires have been produced with heavier dipped finishes.

      1. Overplating

In recent years, platers of tin and tin-lead finishes have been yielding to increase pressures to reduce lead content in the finishes, plant environment and plating waste affluent. More "environmentally friendly" percentages of 90/10, 93/7 and 95/5 tin/lead have replaced the more traditional 60/40 tin-lead and 100 per cent tin plating.All of the  tin and tin lead platings can be applied in various controlled thickness ranges.  Thickness specifications typically indicate a 3-5 micron minimum and are specified  both with and without additional underplatings of nickel and copper. The actual  thickness of the overplate is significant to the lngevity of solderability. Tin and tin-lead finishes are produced in bright, satin and matte finishes. However, specifying the    plating finish is a severely limiting detail in so far as this sonsideration may limit suppliers and supplier processing options.

       2. Underplating

The two most common underplating are nickel and copper. Specifications which   include underplatings are developed for many reasons; base metal isolation, convenience to the electroplater, and short and long term solderability concerns.

Copper as an underplate is chosen typically if nickel cannot be used. When it is used as a "flash" to 1 micron it is mainly employed as a vehicle to prepare the base wire (copper alloys) to be overplated.   When present in 2.5 microns or greater copper will operate as a diffusionary barrier allowing migratory base metal constituents to be absorbed in the highly soluable copper layer. Thus in this manner the migratory constituents do not reach the susceptible tin and tin-lead layer and cause problems      in the overplate ability to wet.

Table 2

Tensile ranges for Round and Square Wire
(ksi.)

Temper C102/C110 C172 C260 C510 C710 C725 C752 52 Alloy
                 
Annealed 30/38 58/78 48/54 43/58 55/72 55/60   72/82
1/8 Hard     50/65         85/195
1/4 Hard 38/48 90/115 62/77 60/76 67/83 55/75 68/84 100/115
1/2 Hard 48/58 110/135 79/94 80/97   70/85 83/97 110/125
3/4 Hard 58 min. 130/155 92/107 96/115 77/92 80/95   115/130
Hard 60 min. 140/165 102/117 102/128   90/110 99/111 125 min.
Full Hard   150/175            
Extra Hard   155/180 115/129          
Spring Temper     120 min. 130 min. 83 min. 105/125    
Super Spring         100 min.      
Pretempered   170/230            

Nickel as an underplate is chosen because of the more desirable properties it has. As   a "flash" it is used mainly to prepare base wire (copper or nickel alloys) for over plating. When nickel is plate .75 micron or more, nickel will sewrve as a significant barrier preventing base metal constituents from migrating through to effect the overplating. Nickel can be electroplated several microns in thickness without problems from      stress cracking.

E. Solderability concerns

Solderability is the joining process which establishes a metallurgical bond between    the wire pin, the filler solder and the wrapping wire. Solderability of metallic surfaces   are judged by the degree of "wetting" during the soldering operation against selected standards. The solderability shelf-life should be guaranteed for 1 year from the date        of the manufacture.

Solderability is specified and interpreted in many ways: personal interpretation, company standard, industry standards, government standards, and military standards.

Most pin wire is produced to a solderability standard, (ie. Company Standard,Mil-Std 202). Standards should be used to inspect incoming wire. The solderability of the wire will ever so slowly degrade as time passes from the date of manufacture.  

Manufacturing companies shipping finished components need to pay attention to the time-effect on on inventory and the clause of the standard that pertains to "passed-on" assurances of tested shelf life. Just because an assembly is produced with wire made originally to military stanbdards does not guarantee that the assembly is guaranteed    to meet the same military standard months later., It must be retested.

Finished transformer coils may contain bobbins months old. These bobbins may be made from wire inventroy which was months old. Wire originally produced with solderability to Mil-Std 202, Method 208. may not be solderable to the same standard months later due to the fact that the standard contains tests which simulate shelf life aging. Steam aging and heat aging are examples of thesetypes of tests. They may  have spent some time as wire inventory, bobbin inventory, or as finished coils. Pin solderability to this level would again have to be reevaluated and recertified. Of course the original wire must meet the tests originally.

F. Surface Treatments

Pin retention forces recently can be increased through serrating, or knurling preplated wire surfaces prior to being inserted into the bobbin. Knurling is possible on round     wire as well as square and rectangular wire. Knurling round wire will cause some increased ovality and square wire some of the dimension tolerance. Tooling typically containing from 33 to 80 TPI (teeth per inch) in a straight pattern appears to be most effective although there are many variations possible.

In lieu of knurling the surface of the pin material, pin retention may be enhanced by coining or upsetting with securing star, flat or barbed feature. Some of this may be performed in tandem with insertion operations or performed separately.

CONCLUSION

The preceding is a quick overview of alloys, cross-sections, underplating and   overplating specifications. Consideration to specifying pin alloys, tolerances, electroplating finishes and surfaces will greatly aid in achieving maximum retention forces and good solderability.
 

REFERENCES

1) William K. Halleran, "An Overview of the Solderability Considerations of Wire", Proceedings of the International Coil Winding Association, November 13-15, 1984.

2) William K. Halleran, "The Bobbin Pin Connector: Square Wire and Solderability Considerations", Proceedings of the International Coil Winding Association,   September 30- October 3, 1985.

3) Standards Handbook, Part 2-Alloy Data, Wrought Copper and Copper Alloy Mill Products, Eighth Edition, 1985, Copper Development Association, Greenwich CT.

4) Annual Book of ASTM Standards,

Nonferrous Metal Products, Copper and Copper Alloys, (1994)

BIOGRAPHY

Jim McGowan graduated from Drexel University, Philadelphia, PA., Bachelors of Science. He has worked 11 years as a Sales Engineer in aluminum master alloys, tantalum, columblum and high strength nickel and nickel cobalt alloys and as a   product specialist in beryllium copper for Kawecki Berylco Industries, Cabot Corporation and NKG Metals Corporation. He has been employed for the last 10years at R&F Alloy Wires, Inc., Fairfield, NJ where he is vice president of sales and marketing.

 

 

Specifications & Data  Packaging  Technical Publications  International Sales  Facilities  Plating  Home

 

125 New Dutch Lane, P.O. Box 10003, Fairfield, NJ 07004, U.S.A.
voice:  973. 227. 6222       fax:  973. 808. 8209       e-mail:
info@rfalloy.com

© copyright 1999, R&F ALLOY WIRES, INC., all rights reserved